Volume 89, 2014

Articles

New attributions to the Sappho-Diosphos Painters’ workshop
A group of black-figure kyathoi reconsidered

This paper proposes to attribute, for the first time, three Attic kyathoi to the Sappho Painter and gathers together other vases that may belong to this late black-figure workshop (end of the 6th- beginning of the 5th century BC). It further confirms through the study of figured decoration and shape that an important part of Attic kyathoi manufactured in this workshop was a legacy left by Psiax, a hypothesis already suggested for a few pieces by C. Jubier-Galinier. A study of shape makes it possible to group vases which would not be comparable on stylistic grounds alone, and it reinforces previous stylistic comparisons of figured decorations. It also points out the importance of the potter’s work in the organization and understanding of Attic ceramic workshops.

The Pontine Marshes (Central Italy): a case study in wetland historical ecology

The citation of natural environmental processes as a key element in the formation of and changes in human culture has been unfashionable for some time. Whilst scepticism of certain unfettered cultural ecological or socioecological theories is understandable, archaeologists often fail to engage fully with the dynamic relationships between people and environment in the past. This paper provides a new assessment of the potential of more nuanced cultural and historical ecological frameworks that explicitly develop notions of environmental knowledge in the investigation of human engagements with the environment. More specifically, this contribution considers the development of the forms of environmental knowledge associated with a Roman wetland, the Pontine Marshes. Changes in settlement activity and practices in this central Italian wetland landscape close to Rome were the product of a complex interplay of elite political initiatives and management projects and local forms of environmental knowledge applied by ordinary people who had to engage with this landscape. The paper comprises an introduction to the research questions and the interpretive framework, followed by an assessment of documentary and recent archaeological research that serve to illustrate the development of human interaction with these marshes. The discussion considers the probable reasons for the waxing and waning of wetland activity, and the nature of different class-based understandings of the wetland during the Roman period.

Città, insediamenti rurali e paesaggi agrari della Daunia tra le guerre sannitiche e l’età post-annibalica

More than twenty years after the publication of Giuliano Volpe’s La Daunia nell’età della romanizzazione, it is important to reflect again on settlement and rural landscapes of Northern Apulia, between the end of the 4th and the beginning of the 2nd century BC, in order to focus on how and in which directions the interpretative scenarios regarding these issues have changed from then to now. This paper aims not to follow the path, still premature, of the overall synthesis on Daunia between the Samnite wars and the age of Hannibal; it intends to present an overview of the results of the most recent research projects carried out in different regional districts, which allow archaeologists to problematize theories and interpretations.

Das Castellum Aquae in Pompeji
Befundbasierte Analyse oder Rückkehr zu alten Glaubenssätzen?

In einer 2008 erschienenen Studie machen J.-P. Adam und P. Varène unter anderem Aussagen zur Funktion der Wasserverteilung im Castellum Aquae in Pompeji. Sie stützen sich dabei auf selektive Beobachtungen von Kalkablagerungen im Zuleitungskanal und im Becken, versuchen, die zur Verfügung stehende Wassermenge zu berechnen usw., lassen dabei aber grundlegende hydrotechnische Kenntnisse vermissen. Sie datieren das Gebäude und vor allem die Fassade augusteisch, letztere im Vergleich mit einem im Haus des L. Caecilius Iucundus gefundenen Flachrelief jedoch auch (zumindest partiell) in die Zeit nach dem Erdbeben von 62 n.Chr., ohne diesen Widerspruch auflösen zu können. Insgesamt fällt ihre Studie weit hinter den aktuellen Forschungsstand zurück.

Im folgenden Beitrag werden meine eigenen Forschungsergebnisse, die im Überschneidungsbereich von Philologie, Archäologie und Hydrotechnik entstanden sind, den Thesen von Adam und Varène korrigierend gegenübergestellt. Es wird anhand von Befunden gezeigt, wie die Wasserverteilung im Castellum Aquae von Pompeji tatsächlich funktioniert hat und wie die Baugeschichte der Anlage in zwei Phasen von spätrepublikanischer bis in augusteische Zeit verlaufen ist. Ein eingeschobener Exkurs beschäftigt sich mit dem genannten Relief und seinen Deutungsproblemen.

The Cancelleria reliefs, Vespasian the younger, and Domitian’s dynastic program
BABESCH Byvanck Award 2013

The present article discusses the various scholarly interpretations of the events depicted on the Cancelleria Reliefs, and identifies the scene in Panel B as the appointment of Titus Flavius Vespasianus the Younger as crown prince by his adoptive father, the emperor Domitian. This event, mentioned by historical accounts and commemorated in one provincial coin issue, was the climactic moment in Domitian’s program for the celebration of the Gens Flavia, which found its most grandiose manifestation in the public buildings that he dedicated in Rome to the cults of his father, brother, and extended family.

Bacchus and Jupiter-Ammon, two bronze sculptures from roman Nijmegen, The Netherlands

In 2008, during a small excavation in the city centre of Nijmegen, an extraordinary bronze hoard came to light. During the Roman period, this area was part of the burial site of Ulpia Noviomagus, the civitas capital of the Batavians that developed from AD 70 onwards, after oppidum Batavorum was destroyed by fire in the Batavian Revolt. The hoard consists of eighty pieces, amongst others fragments of a life-size arm or leg, fragments of a monumental bronze tablet, and heavy ornamental fragments. In this article, two fragments will be presented and placed in their regional context: a fragment of a Jupiter-Ammon herm and a fragment of a large Bacchus statuette.

Wer badet wo und mit wem?
Repräsentations-, Privat- und Dienerschaftsbäder in den kaiserlichen Residenzen der römischen Epoche

While the thermae publicae have been researched by many scholars like I. Nielsen or F. Yegül for decades, little attention has been paid to private baths. This is, despite their importance, particularly the case with the often lavishly decorated palatial baths.

Through my research I developed the theory that there were three kinds of palatial bath buildings, representational baths, private refuges for the emperor as well as some bathing facilities that were built to be used by servants and slaves.

Emilie Haspels and the Fortresses and Monuments of the Phrygian highlands

The starting point for this paper is the publication of I am the Last of the Travelers by C.H. Emilie Haspels, with contributions by Halet Çambel1 (second revised and enlarged edition),2 Istanbul, Archaeology and Art Publications, 2012, 196 pp.; 91 figs, large folded map at end; 24×16.5 cm. – ISBN 978-605-396-029-4. This paper consists of three parts: Part 1 is a review of the book – an autobiographical report edited with great care and expertise by Dr. Dietrich Berndt3 – in which Haspels describes the excavation of Midas City and two survey expeditions in the Phrygian Highlands (1946 and 1950). In Part 2 the author will discuss some specific questions, sites and monuments in the Phrygian Highlands, to elucidate matters that have not been treated in Highlands, or are difficult to appreciate to the full in the enormous mass of the material of the two volumes. In Part 3 the author, who accompanied Haspels on the expeditions of 1953 and 1958 (of which the reports are lacking in the book under review, though an extensive written manuscript is known to exist), will give some further information on the archaeological work that led to Haspels’ masterpiece: The Highlands of Phrygia (1971).

REVIEWS

A. Furtwängler/I. Gagoshidze/H. Löhr/N. Ludwig (eds), Iberia and Rome. The excavations of the palace at Dedoplis Gora and the Roman influence in the Caucasian Kingdom of Iberia (by W. Anderson)

Norbert Kramer, Keramik und Kleinfunde aus Diokaisareia. Diokaisareia in Kilikien: Ergebnisse des Surveys 2001-2006 Band 1 (by Philip Bes)

Christopher P. Dickenson, Onno M. Nijf (eds), Public Space in the Post-classical City. Proceedings of a one day Colloquium held at Fransum 23rd July 2007 (by Mary Jane Cuyler)

Margarita Gleba/Helle W. Horsnaes (eds), Communicating Identity in Italic Iron Age Communities (by Fernando Gilotta)

Fernando Gilotta/Colonna Passaro con contributi di Leopoldo Aveta, Gabriella Ciaccia, Fulvio De Salvia, Angela Izzo, Ciro Piccioli, Antonio Scognamiglio, La necropoli del Migliaro a Cales. Materiali di età arcaica (by Marijke Gnade)

Stefan Zimmer (ed.), Kelten am Rhein. Akten des dreizehnten Internationalen Keltologiekongresses, 23. bis 27. Juli 2007 in Bonn. Vol. 1 Ethnizität und Romanisierung. Vol. 2 Sprachen und Literaturen (by Tatiana Ivleva)

Max Kunze/Kathrin Schade/Elke Mählitz-Galler (eds), Vom Nil aus um die Alte Welt. Rekonstruktionen ägyptischer, minoischer und griechischer Schiffe (by Jean MacIntosh Turfa)

Claudio Giardino (ed.), Archeometallurgia: Dalla Conoscenza alla Fruizione. Atti del Workshop, 22-25 maggio 2006 Cavallino (Le), Convento dei Domenicani (by Jean MacIntosh Turfa)

Cristoforo Grotta, Zeus Meilichios a Selinunte (by Jean MacIntosh Turfa)

Emanuele Greco (ed.), Il santuario delle divinità orientali e i suoi predecessori (Sibari – Casa Bianca): scavi 2007, 2009-2012 (by Jean MacIntosh Turfa)

Jean MacIntosh Turfa (ed.), The Etruscan World (by L.B. van der Meer)

Vincenzo Bellelli/Marco Mazzi, Extispicio. Una “scienza” divinatoria tra Mesopotamia ed Etruria (by L.B. van der Meer)

Wolfram Hoepfner, Halikarnassos und das Maussoleion. Die modernste Stadtanlage und der als Weltwunder gefeierte Grabtempel des karischen Königs Maussolos (by L.B. van der Meer)

Daniela Locatelli, Luigi Malnati, Daniele F. Maras (eds), Storie della prima Parma. Etruschi, Galli, Romani. Le origini della città alla luce delle nuove scoperte archeologiche (by L.B. van der Meer)

Jean MacIntosh Turfa, Divining the Etruscan World. The Brontoscopic Calendar and Religious Practice (by L.B. van der Meer)

Laura Ambrosini, Corpus Speculorum Etruscorum. Italia 7.1. Roma – Museo Nazionale Romano. Museo delle antichità etrusche ed italiche, Sapienza – Università di Roma. Collezione Gorga (by L.B. van der Meer)

Caitlín E. Barrett, Egyptianizing Figurines from Delos, A Study in Hellenistic Religion (by Eva Mol)

Carmela Roscino, Polignoto di Taso (by Eric M. Moormann)

Adolf H. Borbein & Max Kunze (eds), Johann Joachim Winckelmann, Statuenbeschreibungen, Materialien zur „Geschichte der Kunst des Alterthums”, Rezensionen (by Eric M. Moormann)

Natascha Sojc/Aloys Winterling/Ulrike Wulf-Rheidt (eds), Palast und Stadt im severischen Rom (by Eric M. Moormann)

Anna Anguissola (ed.), Privata Luxuria. Towards an Archaeology of Intimacy: Pompeii and Beyond (by Eric M. Moormann)

Martin Disselkamp, „Nichts ist, Rom, dir gleich.” Topographien und Gegenbilder aus dem mittelalterlichen und früh-neuzeitlichen Europa (by Eric M. Moormann)

Brian Madigan, The Ceremonial Sculptures of the Roman Gods (by Eric M. Moormann)

Nicolas Monteix/Nicolas Tran (eds), Les savoirs professionnels des gens de métier. Études sur le monde du travail dans les sociétés urbaines de l’empire romain (by H.W. Pleket)

Patrasso colonia di Augusto e le trasformazioni culturali, politiche ed economiche della Provincia di Acaia agli inizi dell’ età imperiale romana (Atti del Convegno internazionale, Patrassa 23-24 marzo 2006) (by H.W. Pleket)

Eric M. Moormann, Divine Interiors. Mural Paintings in Greek and Roman Sanctuaries (by Gil H. Renberg)

Rosmarie Mösch-Klingele, Braut ohne Bräutigam. Schwarz- und rotfigurige Lutrophoren als Spiegel gesellschaftlicher Veränderungen in Athen (by Angelika Schöne-Denkinger)

Diederik Burgersdijk/Willemijn Waal (eds), Constantinopel, Een mozaïek van de Byzantijnse metropool (by Karin Schuitema)

Elisa Pellegrini, Eros nella Grecia arcaica e classica (by Natascha Sojc)

Stephan Weiß-König, Graffiti auf römischer Gefäßkeramik aus dem Bereich der Colonia Ulpia Traiana/Xanten (by D.C. Steures)

Hans-Joachim Schalles (ed.), Der frühkaiserzeitliche Manuballista aus Xanten-Wardt (by D.C. Steures)

Martin Müller/Thomas Otten/Ulrike Wulf-Rheidt (eds), Schutzbauten und Rekonstruktionen in der Archäologie (by D.C. Steures)

Bernd Liesen (ed.), Terra sigillata in den germanischen Provinzen (by D.C. Steures)

Marcus Reuter/Romina Schiavone (eds), Gefährliches Pflaster. Kriminalität im römischen Reich (by D.C. Steures)

Uwe Peltz/Hans-Joachim Schalles (eds), Der Xantener Knabe. Technologie, Ikonographie, Funktion und Datierung (by D.C. Steures)

Marcus Reuter, Legio XXX Ulpia Victrix. Ihre Geschichte, ihre Soldaten, ihre Denkmäler (by D.C. Steures)

Martin Müller, Xantener Berichte. Grabung – Forschung – Präsentation. Sammelband (by D.C. Steures)

Jack L. Davis/Natalia Vogeikoff-Brogan (eds), Philhellenism, Philanthropy, or Political Convenience? American Archaeology in Greece (by Gert Jan van Wijngaarden)